Mariah Carey’s 1990s Outfits Are Actually A Brilliant Source Of Style Inspiration

Extra in the best possible way...

Mariah Carey's 1990s style

by Laura Antonia Jordan |
Updated on

The ’90s were the era of sloppy, grungy threads and sleek, understated minimalism. It was slip dresses, shirts and barely-there sandals. It was Jennifer Aniston in a tank top, combat pants and flip flops and Sarah Jessica Parker in a simple black dress and biker boots. It was the decade of low-maintenance style.

Mariah Carey at the Soul Train Lady of Soul Awards in 1998
In a look-at-me gold mini dress and shades, Mariah owns the spotlight at the 1998 Soul Train Lady of Soul Awards. ©Getty

Except it wasn’t that for Mariah Carey. But she never claimed to be low-maintenance did she? (A telling indicator of society’s double gender standards, this means she has been repeatedly cast as an, ahem,difficultdiva whereas men? Well, they can be as tricky and demanding as they want with little to no clapback). But Mimi doesn’t likely give a falsetto hoot about what anyone thinks, and in fact leans into her unabashedly high-maintenance life and style. In her new memoir The Meaning of Mariah Carey she even acknowledges her ‘propensity for extraness’. Having experienced a grim childhood, who could really blame her for revelling in the lavish spoils of her success?

Mariah Carey at the MTV Video Music Awards in 1997
**INSERT FIRE EMOJIS** At the 1997 MTV Music Awards. We are not worthy. ©Getty

And so, Carey’s 1990s style was anything is, indeed, extra in the best possible way. Her go tos? Super-tight silhouettes, cropped tops, thigh-grazing hemlines and dangerously high slits (worn with opaque tights, curiously, at the 1996 Billboard Awards - she is only human). It was a look that didn’t so much belong in the spotlight as outright own it. Gold and opulent embellishment are also recurring themes in her fashion arsenal because, well, go figure – she is royalty.

That’s not to say Carey didn’t know how to do dressed down as well, albeit in a private-jet and limo kind of way. Admittedly there are concessions to the decade’s more relaxed favourites – hello jeans with cut off waistbands and bomber jackets worn shrugged off the shoulders. Even the humble cardigan got the haute treatment in Mimi’s hands – she wore them with everything from Clueless-style plaid skirts to jeans and vest top. Whether on or off duty, however, she was and is always impeccably coiffed.

Mariah Carey at the Calvin Klein FW94 show
Cher Horowitz called, she wants her look back. Mariah went for a preppier vibe at the Calvin Klein FW94 show. ©Getty

There are many things that no doubt spring to mind when you think of Mariah Carey: the voice, the riders, Christmas, Glitter (it would probably be best for all of us if that was forgotten) but her style isn’t usually one of them. The thing is, however, whether you love it or loathe it, you have to admire her for owning it. She doesn't make an empty show of being ‘just like us’. And good for her, because she is not just like us – she is Mariah Carey for goodness sake.

Mariah Carey at the Butterfly album launch in 1997
For her Butterfly album launch party in 1967 Mariah went for a mini skirt, asymmetric cropped top and barely-there sandals. That chain belt is truly of its time. ©Getty

You have to admire the unflinching confidence and vision of a woman who wears what the hell she wants, simply because she feels good and looks unapologetically hot in it. Carey gets dressed on her own terms. Why blend in when you can stand out? Her approach to clothes is rather like her approach to interior design, it’s about locating her own comfort zone, whatever that looks like: ‘I chose to do the colours neutral so they’re not jarring,’ she explained in her seminal appearance on MTV's Cribs in 2002. ‘Because I have enough jarring things that happen to me on a daily basis’. Amen to that.

Gallery

Fashback: Mariah Carey

Mariah Carey & Tommy Mottola, 19951 of 12

Mariah Carey & Tommy Mattola, 1995

Fun fact: that knitted vest is actually part of a twin set. Here with her ex-husband Tommy Mottola in 1995.

Giorgio Armani, 19962 of 12

Mariah Carey in Giorgio Armani, 1996

Knockout fashion moment! This black and white striped Giorgio Armani column gown feels timeless and modern all at once.

Grammy Awards, 19963 of 12

Grammy Awards, 1996

For the Grammys in 1996, it was a midriff-revealing top and a maxi skirt.

Billboard Awards, 19964 of 12

Billboard Awards, 1996

An odd mash-up of glamour and practicality. The super-high thigh slit says: I am hot. The brown opaque tights say: we all make odd choices one in a while.

Armani party, 19965 of 12

Armani party, 1996

It's short. It's tight. It's a classic Mariah look at an Armani party in 1996.

Amsterdam, 19966 of 12

Amsterdam, 1996

Mimi went for a belly-baring, optic print halterneck in Amsterdam in 1996.

American Music Awards, 19967 of 12

American Music Awards, 1996

Only a real boss can pull off a leather suit – which is exactly what Mariah opted for at the 1996 American Music Awards. Shades: essential.

Party, 19978 of 12

Party, 1997

Short + shimmering is a Mariah approved power move.

Blockbuster Entertainment Awards, 19989 of 12

Blockbuster Entertainment Awards, 1998

Take one short dress and make it even shorter. At the Blockbuster Entertainment Awards in 1998.

Event, 199910 of 12

Event, 1999

A total '90s mood. Frayed edge denim and a cropped cardigan were her off-duty go tos.

Blockbuster Entertainment Awards, 199911 of 12

Blockbuster Entertainment Awards, 1999

Another awards ceremony and another cropped top and maxi skirt pairing.

New York, 199912 of 12

New York, 1999

How to do off-duty the diva way: frayed denim, bomber jacket, cropped vest and under no circumstances skip your blowdry.

Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us