‘Downton Abbey’ Creator Thinks ‘The Crown’ Was Unfair To Prince Philip

the crown prince philip

by Jazmin Kopotsha |
Updated on

While we're all overwhelmingly engrossed inNetflix's The Crown (who doesn't love a big budget period drama?) it's easy to blur the lines between fact and royal fiction. Though the show is widely praised and boasts an incredibly loyal fan base, anticipating how the series would reflect the current royal family as it catches up with real life was always going to be a bit tricky.

Downton Abbey creator Lord Julian Fellowes thinks that the show wasn't particularly fair to Prince Philip in it's second season, however. Though he praises The Crown's acting and writing talent, speaking on Katie Couric's podcast Fellowes said: 'For me, I'm not completely comfortable with dramatising people who are still alive and still living their lives. Because I think it's possible to be unfair.'

'And in the second series, I didn't think it was fair to Prince Philip, to the Duke of Edinburgh, based on very little.', he added.

Fellows was careful to add that he'd probably be punished for criticising what he openly acknowledges to be 'a great success and it deserves to be'. However when it comes to relaying the lives of living people, the thinks the lines are less clear.

He said: 'I think when people are still alive, living their lives, doing a good job and popular and loved, do they deserve it? And in that sense, I'm not sure they do'.

'I think that a lot of it was based on obviously very good research, but some of it was not. Some of it was extrapolation from a rumour or someone's rather prejudiced account. And then it was presented as fact. I'm not sure that's just.'

Credit where credit's due, of course. Though we're unsure of how the Duke feels about the series, Fellows is still a fan of the team behind the how. 'I'm a big fan of Peter Morgan, I repeat that', he added. 'I think he's the best writer on television at the moment. And it's deservedly successful as far as I'm concerned.'

As season 3 of The Crown draws closer, we'll undoubtedly be paying extra attention to how the series relays the lives of some of Britain's living royals.

MORE: We Break Down How 'The Crown' Compares To Real Life

Gallery

The Crown real life versus TV USE - Grazia

queen elizabeth1 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

Queen Elizabeth II...

Season two sees Elizabeth more established in her role as Queen, but having to contend with a tumultuous political climate and tensions in her marriage.

the queen claire foy2 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Claire Foy

The Crown marks the second time that Claire Foy has played a Queen: she previously starred as Anne Boleyn in the BBC's adaptation of Wolf Hall.

Queen Elizabeth II 1970s3 of 32
CREDIT: Shutterstock

Queen Elizabeth II...

After the tumult of seasons one and two, the third installment of The Crown should cover a happier period for Her Majesty, as she approaches her Silver Jubilee. She will, however, have her elder children's relationship dramas to contend with.

olivia colman the crown season three4 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Olivia Colman (season three)

Olivia Colman steals the show in everything she stars in, from Peep Show to Broadchurch to Fleabag, and this, her biggest role yet, will undoubtedly bring her some well-deserved international acclaim. It takes a national treasure to play a national treasure, surely?

prince philip the crown5 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh...

Prince Philip actually only became a Prince of the United Kingdom in 1957, when it was announced that he'd be known as His Royal Highness The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh.

prince philip the crown6 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Matt Smith

Matt Smith's Philip becomes more of a central focus for The Crown's second season, which explores the Duke's place in the royal family while hinting at his rumoured infidelity.

princess margaret portrait7 of 32
CREDIT: STF/AFP/Getty Images

Princess Margaret...

Widely perceived as the Queen's 'wilder' sister, Margaret associated with a more bohemian circle in the 60s and 70s.

vanessa kirby the crown8 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Vanessa Kirby

Prior to playing Princess Margaret, Vanessa balanced stage work with credits in film and TV productions like Great Expectations, About Time and Me Before You. She's also recently starred opposite Tom Cruise in the latest installment of the Mission Impossible franchise_._

princess margaret 1960s9 of 32
CREDIT: Shutterstock

Princess Margaret...

The Crown's resident historical expert Robert Lacey has already confirmed that season three will explore the tensions in Princess Margaret's marriage; it's thought that the new episodes will also feature her 'loving friendship' with garden designer Roddy Llewellyn.

the crown season three helena bonham carter10 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Helena Bonham Carter (season three)

We can't wait to see what Helena Bonham Carter, a period drama veteran of the big and small screen, brings to the role of Princess Margaret. 'The only thing I can guarantee is that I'm shorter than Vanessa [Kirby],' she's joked.

queen mother11 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Mother...

Elizabeth, the Queen Mother, was widely considered among the most popular members of the royal family, and was active in public life even as she turned 100.

victoria hamilton the crown12 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Victoria Hamilton

Fan of Doctor Foster? Victoria Hamilton's turn as Gemma's neighbour Anna was certainly a contrast to her royal role as the Queen Mum.

king george iv13 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

King George VI...

Known as Bertie to his family, George VI never expected to become King. Upon the abdication of his older brother, however, the throne was his.

jared harris the crown14 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Jared Harris

The son of actor Richard (aka Dumbledore from The Philosopher's Stone), Jared Harris' screen credits include Mad Men, Sherlock Holmes and Lincoln.

Antony Armstrong-Jones15 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

Antony Armstrong-Jones...

Antony Armstrong-Jones had a notoriously tempestuous relationship with Princess Margaret, but even after their 1978 divorce, he continued as the royal family's photographer of choice.

matthew goode the crown16 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Matthew Goode

Matthew Goode is something of a period drama mainstay, having previously appeared in the likes of Downton Abbey, Brideshead Revisited and The Imitation Game.

lord snowdon 1970s17 of 32
CREDIT: Shutterstock

Antony Armstrong-Jones, Lord Snowdon

The new Lord Snowdon's biggest royal responsibility came in 1969, when he was asked to design the set for his nephew Charles' investiture as Prince of Wales at Caernarfon Castle. A famed fashion and portrait photographer, he tried to give the ceremony a more contemporary feel: the visiting dignitaries sat on minimalist red chairs, which were then made available to buy.

the crown season three ben daniels18 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Ben Daniels (season three)

Ben Daniels' CV is nothing if not diverse. He's appeared on Broadway, had a recurring role in Netflix's House of Cards, and even starred in the US TV version of Jesus Christ Superstar (you know, the one with John Legend?) as judge Pontius Pilate. Musical episode of The Crown, please?

jackie kennedy19 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

Jackie Kennedy...

The Crown marks the second screen incarnation of former First Lady Jackie Kennedy of 2017: Natalie Portman earned an Oscar nod for unconventional biopic Jackie earlier this year.

jackie kennedy jodi balfour20 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Jodi Balfour

South African actress Jodi Balfour most recently starred as DI Elaine Shephard in the BBC's police procedural Rellik; prior to that, her biggest role was in Canadian TV drama Bomb Girls .

john f kennedy21 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

John F. Kennedy...

John F. Kennedy made just one state visit to Buckingham Palace during his presidency, which took place in the summer of 1961. The real life events form the subject of 'Dear Mrs President' in The Crown's second season.

john f kennedy the crown22 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Michael C. Hall

American actor Michael C. Hall is best known for his roles as the serial killer of the title in Dexter and as a mortician in Six Feet Under.

Edward VIII23 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

The Duke of Windsor, formerly Edward VIII...

Britain was gripped by scandal - not to mention a constitutional crisis - when King Edward VIII proposed to Wallis Simpson, an American divorcée who was still technically married to her second husband.

duke of windsor the crown24 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Alex Jennings

Alex Jennings is another Crown star to have previously played a different member of the royal family on screen: he starred as Prince Charles opposite Helen Mirren in The Queen.

wallis simpson25 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

Wallis Simpson, the Duchess of Windsor...

Upon her third marriage, American socialite Wallis Simpson became the Duchess of Windsor, though she was never truly accepted by the royal family.

wallis simpson the crown26 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Lia Williams

Alongside her TV roles, actress Lia Williams has starred in a number of plays, directed short films and runs a production company with her husband.

peter townsend real life27 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

Group Captain Peter Townsend...

A royal equerry from 1944 to 1953, Peter Townsend's romance with Princess Margaret caused a scandal due to his being recently divorced from his wife.

peter townsend the crown28 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Ben Miles

Ben Miles has previously appeared in shows like Cold Feet, Coupling and the BBC's Shakespeare adaptation, The Hollow Crown.

Prince Charles and Princess Anne29 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

Prince Charles and Princess Anne...

Before Charles and Anne headed off to boarding school, they were educated by a governess at Buckingham Palace.

Prince Charles and Princess Anne30 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Billy Jenkins and Lyla Barrett-Rye

Billy has previous appeared in Channel 4's Humans, while Lyla played a younger version of Romola Garai's title character in a recent adaptation of Emma.

lord mountbatten the crown31 of 32
CREDIT: Getty

Lord Mountbatten...

Philip's Uncle was born Prince Louis of Battenberg, a title which was dropped in anticipation of anti-German sentiment ahead of WWI. A descendent of Queen Victoria, he was also Elizabeth's second cousin once removed.

lord mountbatten the crown32 of 32
CREDIT: Netflix

Played by Greg Wise

You'll probably know Greg Wise for his role as the dashing but caddish Willoughby in the 1995 screen version of Sense and Sensibility (in which he starred opposite future wife Emma Thompson).

Follow Jazmin on Instagram @JazKopotsha

Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us