Whatever decisions women make about feeding are their own, very personal and should never, ever be questioned, shamed or up for debate. This is not an article where this is in any way up for debate.
To read again this week, that a mother has claimed a Sainsbury' staff member asked her to stop breastfeeding her baby in its carpark because it was 'inappropriate' is something that will surely enrage all of us. And if it doesn't, it should.
Perennially, stories about mothers being told to stop feeding, cover up, or kicked out of public buildings, cafes and types of public transport for breastfeeding, or posting pictures on various social media platforms, rear their heads and it's just EXHAUSTING.
Why, in 2022 is this still happening?
The latest story to hit headlines allegedly took place outside a Sainsbury’s store in Worcestershire on the evening of Friday 24 June. Beth Coles, 25, told The Independent she left her partner in the store and went back to the couple's car to feed their 4-week-old baby Rosie. She said she kept her t-shirt on and used a muslin cloth to cover Rosie, but was spotted by a female member of staff who she says came over to the car and knocked on the window. "She said, 'Can you stop doing that please? I think it's inappropriate'," says Cole.
In a statement to The Independent, Sainsbury’s said it has issued an apology to Coles and that it is investigating the incident.
“We have apologised to Ms Coles for this unacceptable experience, and we have reassured her that breastfeeding is very welcome in our stores,” a spokesperson said.
“We are investigating with the store and further training will be provided to our colleagues where necessary.”
This latest incident follows that of Swindon's Holly Chapman, who was kicked off the number 17 bus in 2021 with her daughters, Gracie, three, and Raiya, 18 weeks, after she started feeding Raiya on the bus.
As anyone who has ever had to breastfeed in a car or on a bus (or a wall, or the floor, or a rickety old chair in the 'breastfeeding lounge' at a department store) will attest, Beth or Holly should be given a medal. Instead, Holly says she was asked to get off the bus.
“My little girl was crying because she needed to eat, so I got her out of the pushchair to feed her, and then the driver told me not to," the 28-year-old told the Swindon Advertiser at the time. “I didn’t know what to do, a woman was tutting, but I don’t know if that was at me or him. I felt so choked up, I tried to brush what happened off, but it impacted me a lot more than I thought.”
No matter your thoughts on feeding, surely most will feel upset to read that Holly then added: “I didn’t realise how much it had affected me until I noticed I was asking people’s permission to feed her in public. This has never happened to me before and now I feel as if I can’t connect with Raiya in the same way because I’m too worried about what other people are thinking.
“I’ve had random comments made from people before. They’ve said ‘it’s disgusting’ and things like that, but I’ve never been thrown off a bus.
“People need to be educated and made aware that it’s perfectly normal and legal. I have postnatal depression, I had it with Gracie and now with Raiya, and this has really impacted that. I feel more anxious now. I'm getting the support I need, but with what happened on the bus, it hasn’t helped.”
The bus firm's manager promised to investigate.
Meanwhile, Beth says: "I just want to stop breastfeeding entirely now. It's hard enough anyway with BPD (borderline personality disorder) and post-natal depression to find the effort to do it, but there's no point if I'm going to get this reaction."
It would be easy to talk about low rates of breastfeeding in the UK (statistics from UNICEF found that rates of exclusive breastfeeding at six weeks were 24% and at six months are around one per cent) and how stories like this impact women choosing to breastfeed now or in the future.
But that just feeds into more debate around promotion of any kind of feeding over another and ultimately, surely we can swerve debates around the 'right' way to feed babies and just be outraged regardless that a woman was humiliated in such a way? For doing something she is allowed to LEGALLY DO, it's a law, it's written down.
And be frustrated that despite feeling like we've been reading these stories for decades and they're still happening?
To just feel TIRED, because sometimes it feels like no matter how much we're told the world is changing for women for the better it doesn't feel like there won't always be someone tutting, staring or making a face - or that this could happen to you too one day.
Sometimes it's great to end on a moment of hope, an upside or a solution. But sometimes, this time, there doesn't seem much more to say than FFS, WHEN WILL THIS END?
Best Parenting Books
1. How to Stop Losing Your Sh*t with Your Kids, By Carla Naumburg PhD

View offer
Pragmatic about helping you work through your sh*t to be a more present and positive parent. Increasingly relevant to today's parents, who are more overloaded, overwhelmed, and overworked than ever before, Carla Naumburg has the antidote to the feelings of complete despair and rage. With some humour too…
2. There's No Such Thing As 'Naughty', By Kate Silverton

View offer
This Sunday Times Bestseller details the secret to tackling tantrums, tears and laying the foundations for your child's mental health. In There's No Such Thing As 'Naughty', mum to two young children, journalist and children's mental health advocate Kate Silverton shares her groundbreaking new approach to parenting under-fives that helps to make family life a breeze!
3. How to Raise Kids Who Aren't Assholes, By Melinda Wenner Moyer

View offer
As Melinda's children grew, she found that one huge area was ignored in the realm of parenting advice: how do we make sure our kids don't grow up to be assholes? How to Raise Kids Who Aren't Assholes is a researched, evidence-based guide that provides a fresh, often surprising perspective on parenting issues, from toddlerhood through the teenage years.
4. Why Did No One Tell Me?: How to Protect Heal and Nurture Your Body Through Motherhood

View offer
For too long, women have been told that debilitating conditions following pregnancy are normal and something they have to just put up with. Emma Brockwell is on a mission to change this. In this guide, Emma combines her expertise as a specialist women's health physiotherapist with personal experience to create a warm and informative handbook to help pregnant women and new mums take control and care for their changing bodies. Find out how to:
5. The Gentle Discipline Book, By Sarah Ockwell-Smith

View offer
In The Gentle Discipline Book, Sarah Ockwell-Smith debunks many commonly held beliefs about punishment and motivation and provides an alternative approach that will empower you to discipline your child in an effective way and with respect. Gentle discipline is not about mollycoddling your child or being a pushover - it means understanding your child, having realistic expectations of them, and responding to their misbehaviour appropriately. It focuses on teaching and learning, not punishment or rewarding.
6. No Bad Kids: Toddler Discipline Without Shame

View offer
No Bad Kids is a collection of Janet's most popular and widely read articles pertaining to common toddler behaviours and how respectful parenting practices can be applied to benefit both parents and children. It covers such common topics as punishment, cooperation, boundaries, testing, tantrums, hitting, and more.
7. When The World Feels Like A Scary Place, By Abigail Gewirtz

View offer
This book by prominent child psychologist Dr Abi Gewirtz, brings solutions to a problem that is only going to get worse - how bad things happening in the world affect our children, and how we can raise engaged and confident kids in spite of them. Through conversation scripts, talking points, prompts and insightful asides, When the World Feels Like a Scary Place is an indispensable guide to talking to our kids about the big things that worry them - making us calmer parents with more resilient children.
8. Queen Bees and Wannabes

View offer
A revised and updated version of Rosalind Wiseman's groundbreaking book for a new generation of girls. Packed with insights about technology's impact on Girl World and enlivened with the experiences of girls, boys, and parents, the book that inspired the hit movie Mean Girls (YES REALLY) offers concrete strategies to help you empower your daughter to be socially competent and treat herself with dignity.
9. How Toddlers Thrive, By Tovah P. Klein

View offer
Leading toddler expert Dr Tovah P. Klein reveals why age two to five is the most crucial time for a child's brain development and how parents can harness this period to have a lifelong positive effect on their children's lives. With chapters on everyday routines, tantrums, managing change and avoiding toddler shaming, this smart and useful guide promises to inspire you to be a better parent. Sarah Jessica Parker says: 'Tovah taught me how to resist the temptation to fix everything, and instead give my children the opportunity to learn how to problem-solve for themselves.'
10. The Montessori Toddler

View offer
This book promises to not only help you become a more effective parent but actually change how you see your children. Written by Montessori educator Simone Davies, this book shows you how to bring the educational values of a Montessori classroom into your home-while
11. Parenting The Sh*t Out Of Life

View offer
From Grazia columnist Anna Whitehouse aka Mother Pukka and Matt Farquharson aka Papa Pukka, comes the Sunday Times bestselling account of parenting told from both perspectives, and a handy guide (kind of) on how to raise a small human. The must-read for all parents and parents-to-be - and possibly the best (or worst) baby shower gift you could ever give a prospective mum or dad...
12. What Mummy Makes

View offer
Promising 130 recipes that will suit six-month-olds AND the rest of the family, this book could save you a lot of hassle when it comes to dinnertime…
13. Sex, Likes And Social Media: Talking To Our Teens In The Digital Age, By Deana Puccio And Allison Havey

View offer
Based on their professional work with young people, parents and teachers – and their experiences with their own children – Deana Puccio and Allison Havey give you the tools to talk to children who are digital natives with experiences wildly different from their parents'.
14. I Am Not Your Baby Mother

View offer
A thought-provoking, urgent and inspirational guide to life as a Black mother. It explores the various stages between pregnancy and waving your child off at the gates of primary school while facing hurdles such as white privilege, racial micro-aggression and unconscious bias at every point. Candice does so with her trademark sense of humour and refreshing straight-talking, and the result is a call-to-arms that will allow mums like her to take control, scrapping the parenting rulebook to mother their own way.
15. The Calm And Happy Toddler, By Dr Rebecca Chicot

View offer
You think a newborn is the hard bit… and then you meet your little toddler. This book promises to help you, gently, through tantrums, night-waking, potty-training and all the fun stuff that goes with having a toddler. Dr Rebecca Chicot has a PhD in Parenting and Child Development from Cambridge University.
16. How To Talk So Little Kids Will Listen

View offer
Tried and tested communication strategies to survive - and thrive - with kids ages 2-7. Users have rated this book for having a helpful toolbox of tricks that are easy to understand and carry out.
17. Calm Parents, Happy Kids: The Secrets Of Stress-Free Parenting, By Dr Laura Markham

View offer
Most parenting books focus on changing a child's behaviour, but this book says the truth is that children only change when their relationship with their parents changes. In Calm Parents, Happy Kids, Dr Laura Markham introduces an approach to parenting that eliminates threats, power struggles and manipulation, in favour of setting limits with empathy and communication. Bringing together the latest research in brain development with a focus on emotional awareness (for both parents and children), it will appeal to all parents who don't want to force their children into compliance and lose their temper, but want to keep calm and help their children want to behave.
18. 15-Minute Parenting 0-7 Years: Quick And Easy Ways To Connect With Your Child, By Joanna Fortune

View offer
This also comes in a version for 8-12-year-olds and posits that just 15 minutes of mindful playtime each day in your and your child's routine could change behaviour. Created with busy parents in mind, psychotherapist and parenting expert Joanna Fortune has devised a simple but effective method to build quality playful time together at home, structured around 15-minute games that can be easily incorporated into your existing daily routine.
19. The Joy Journal for Magical Everyday Play

View offer
With a foreword written by Fearne Cotton and written by Russell Brand's wife and mother to his two children, this book has star ratings. But it's also hugely useful and full of games and tips to keep children preoccupied in ways that don't involve screens, which everyone knows is very much half the battle of parenthood...
20. French Children Don't Throw Food

View offer
Part travel book and autobiography, this book shares journalist Pamela's parenting tips she learned from living in France. And, for added glam, it's set to be made into a film, starring Anne Hathaway...
21. The Whole-Brain Child

View offer
Designed to help children of different ages, this pioneering, practical book for parents, neuroscientist Daniel J. Siegel and parenting expert Tina Payne Bryson explain the new science of how a child's brain is wired and how it matures. Different parts of a child's brain develop at different speeds and understanding these differences can help you turn any outburst, argument, or fear into a chance to integrate your child's brain and raise calmer, happier children.
22. The Book You Wish Your Parents Had Read (And Your Children Will Be Glad That You Did), By Philippa Perry

View offer
Philippa Perry has been a psychotherapist for the past twenty years. She lives in London with her husband the artist Grayson Perry, and they have a grown-up daughter, Flo. Billed as a book for parents and children (and those who aren't yet parents), this book comprehensively covers lots of different stages of life and has a host of celebrity fans from Nigella Lawson to Fearne Cotton.
23. Your Baby Week By Week

View offer
The book to shove in your pregnant friend's hands and tell them to only read week by week. A helpful manual of things your baby might and could be doing, week by week. As with all books, best taken with a dose of salt too – use the helpful bits, ignore the unhelpful/ones you can't quite face (i.e. the sleep bits…)
24. Nobody Told Me

View offer
If it's weaning or sleep-training schedules you're looking for, this might not help exactly, but this book of poetry will make you smile. And probably nod your head a lot. And sometimes cry, and sometimes feel understood. Which goes much further than you'd think.
25. The Second Baby Book, By Sarah Ockwell-Smith

View offer
This guide examines the specific issues that can arise with a second pregnancy and birth. From the common concerns about siblings, such as how to prepare your firstborn for what's to come, to how to cope with the practicalities of life with two young children. And the feelings parents are likely to experience, too - because it's easy to forget about this part.
26. Between: A guide for parents of eight to thirteen-year-olds

View offer
Raising a teenager can leave you feeling like a parenting beginner all over again. Children in the 'between' stage change daily, leaving parents struggling to understand the child they once thought they knew. In Between by parenting expert Sarah Ockwell-Smith uses biology, psychology and sociology of adolescence to give readers practical parenting advice that you can use to help your child through the tricky transition from childhood to adulthood.
27. How to Talk so Kids Will Listen and Listen so Kids Will Talk

View offer
Parenting experts Adele Faber and Elaine Mazlish provide effective step-by-step techniques to help you improve and enrich your relationships with your children. Read this guide to learn how to break a pattern of arguments, cope with your child's negative feelings, engage your child's co-operation, set clear limits, express your anger without being hurtful and resolve family conflicts peacefully.
28. The Danish Way Of Parenting

View offer
What makes Denmark the happiest country in the world, and how do Danish parents raise happy, confident, successful kids, year after year? This upbeat and practical guide reveals the six essential principles that have been working for parents in Denmark for decades:
29. Baby Knows Best

View offer
Baby Knows Best is a comprehensive guide that shows parents how to respond to their babies' cues and signals; how to develop healthy sleep habits, why babies need uninterrupted playtime and how to set clear consistent limits. After reading as parents you will be more relaxed and also have more confident, self-reliant children.
30. Calmer, Easier, Happier Boys

View offer
Calmer Easier Happier Boys sees parenting expert Noel Janis-Norton explains simple strategies for the unique challenges of raising motivated, cooperative and confident boys. Using the stellar techniques Noel has developed over many years of working with families, parents can get back in charge. Living with boys can become calmer, easier and happier.