We’re not even a week into All Stars, yet the show has already delivered the drama – with ex’s Gabby Allen and Marcel Somerville battling it out onscreen, before Kaz Crossley took issue with newcomer Casey O’Gorman.
The second bombshell of the series, Love Island All Stars 2025 has seen Casey, 28, make his return to the villa for the third year in a row.
Yes, you read that right. Third time’s the charm.
Only appearing on our screens for the first time back in 2023, Casey has taken his islander status seriously in the 24 months since. After finishing his series in January 2023, he returned for All Stars last January with his bestie Tom Clare. Still on the lookout for love, the star has once again beat his January blues by jetting off on holiday in the form of a stint on the ITV dating show.
However, his entrance didn’t go down well with all islanders…
Before he even had a chance to sit down, Casey found himself in Kaz Crossley’s firing line – as she blasted him in front of their fellow islanders. Minutes after walking into the villa, the islanders gathered around the firepit to ask Casey about his ideal woman. Seizing her moment to spill the tea, Kaz remarked, ‘Love Island girls… outside the villa, too.’
The pair then began to argue, with Kaz declaring, ‘Georgia [Harrison] is one of my friends and you didn’t treat her well.’ Hitting back, Casey insisted it was just something ‘you heard,’ – with Kaz insisting, ‘You f*cked over my friend.’
In case you’re feeling confused, this drama doesn’t really involve Kaz – but rather, centres around her close friendship with Georgia Harrison. Georgia appeared on All Stars last year, opening the door to a rather rocky relationship with Casey…
What happened between Casey and Georgia?
Casey O’Gorman and Georgia Harrison’s story actually begins long before All Stars landed on our screens. Socialising in the same islander circles, the pair had naturally met on the outside – having a brief fling before reuniting on All Stars.
At the time, a source said Georgia was ‘really keen’ on the ‘cheeky chappy’, adding, ‘Casey has really enjoyed the high life since Love Island and wanted to stay single so they kept things casual. He’s the one that got away.’
When the pair were finally reunited in the villa, they sat down to discuss their split – leading to a rather awkward conversation about Casey’s dead grandad...
Speaking to her ex, Georgia said, ‘You acted like you really cared about me during the time we did speak. You always said you really liked me.’ Adding that Casey failed to make an effort for her birthday, Georgia admitted that she had blocked him on Instagram after being ghosted for two weeks.
Explaining his actions, Casey then shared, ‘Do you really want to know what did push me back? You know me, I’m not really much of a spiritual person… You mentioned my grandad and stuff like that, and it really threw me off.’
‘You started to say that you saw my dead grandad and that he wishes me well. And I was like, this is just way too much.’
Defending her spiritual chat with Casey’s dead relative, Georgia insisted, ‘No, I was saying that when I was meditating, I got an experience where I felt I was sensing things from the other side and that people are still around. I was just feeling really connected, really guided, and I wanted to share that with you.’
The pair agreed to disagree, squashing any chance of a romantic reconciliation. However, Georgia did open up about their fallout when appearing on Olivia Attwood’s So Wrong It’s Right podcast.
Describing losing his grandparents as ‘really hard’ for Casey, Georgia explained, ‘What I was trying to say was, I think they’re still with you, I think they’re still on your journey, I think they still guide you, and they probably take a lot of peace out of getting to see you do so well in your life. I wasn’t trying to say, “Just bumped into your dead grandad in Tesco, he’s looking fly.'
While Kaz’s comments hint that it may not be entirely friendly between these two ex’s, Georgia did take some time to send a quick message to her former flame. Commenting on Casey’s return to the villa, the star wrote, ‘Grandad said good luck.’
Case closed!
Charlotte Roberts is a news and entertainment writer at Grazia UK. She spends her days covering everything celebrity, culture, and entertainment.