Why Breadcrumbing Is The Lowest Form Of Digital Communication

The frustrating trail that leads to nowhere...

breadcrumbing definition dating term

by Vicky Spratt |
Updated on

I used to experience breadcrumbing several times a year and it was hell.

Sometimes at predictable moments (birthdays, Valentine’s Day, Christmas, late on a Sunday night) but, mostly, it was out of the blue. I’d check my phone, and butterflies would ensue. Their cause? A message that would simply say ‘how are you’, perhaps an invitation to ‘hang out soon’ or a string of like notifications which informed me that he’d been going through my Instagram archive. Fool that I am, I would always reply.

He was someone I had almost dated on and off for years. Frustrating and flakey as he was, I would fall for it every time and respond to his provocations. In return to my response…tumbleweed. I now know that I was being ‘breadcrumbed’. Guy one, let’s call him ‘the academic’ was a serial breadcrumber. But he’s not the only one out there guilty of this unfathomable and unproductive behaviour.

What Is The Definition Of Breadcrumbing?

Breadcrumbing, a recently coined term, has given a name to an age old digital dating dilemma. Being able to attach a label to the problem is satisfying and concisely cathartic. At the time when I was being breadcrumbed regularly I would send wordy rants to express my annoyance, now I could just say ‘oi, stop breadcrumbing me’.

For those who have never had the misfortune of being breadcrumbed this is how Urban Dictionary defines it:

‘The act of sending out flirtatious, but non-committal text messages (i.e. “breadcrumbs”) to members of the opposite sex in order to lure a sexual partner without expending much effort.’

See also ‘Hansel and Gretelling’ – ‘When a girl or guy gives someone just enough attention to keep their hope of a relationship alive.’

How Breadcrumbing Became The Most Relevant Dating Term Of All

There is, right now, a breadcrumbing epidemic. Take my friend Nalani (not her real name), 27. Nalani is currently single and being periodically breadcrumbed by a ghost from her past. She doesn’t really use Instagram, but when she checks it she finds numerous notifications from the ghost, someone she worked with five years ago but never actually spoke to one on one during their time in the confines of the same office.

The ghost followed Nalani on Instagram and has been liking her posts, old and new, ever since. When it first started happening she thought it was ‘weird’, two months on how does she feel about it? ‘He’s actually quite fit’ she says, ‘Charlie if you’re reading this I’m DTF’. So would she just rather he got on with it and made his intentions clear? ‘Yes!’ she says, ‘mostly I’d like him to just ask me out.’

For the breadcrumber, dropping tiny morsels of attention is a way of letting the object of their very divided attention know they’re moderately interested. It could be an effective way of opening up a dialogue or laying the foundations of a meaningful real life encounter. So why, so often, does the breadcrumb trail become little more than a road to nowhere?

Dr Emma Short is the Director of the National Centre for Cyberstalking Research. I figure if anyone can shed some light on this, it’s her. ‘Largely’ she tells me, ‘it’s part of the ‘shop window’ perception that we’re increasingly seeing created by apps like Tinder. You browse as a past time, rather than with the intent to communicate.’

We can hide behind our screens, between us pressing a button and someone receiving a notification here can be hundreds, if not millions, of miles and even entire continents. Does Dr Short think we’ve become detached from the impact of our digital actions? She explains that apps like Tinder and Instagram are ‘disinhibiting’, people using them ‘forget or filter out the fact that there are recipients and viewers to what they’re doing. You can be in your own home, in your pyjamas and interacting with someone’ she explains, ‘I think that’s where this comes from.’

The issue seems to be one of people acting on impulse without thinking it through or considering the fall out. 100 years ago if the one that got away popped into your mind you could sit down, write a heartfelt letter, put it on your sideboard and wait until you could get to the post office to send it.

Sure, the fact that we’re all a few clicks away from one another is a great thing, but does it somehow devalue our connections with one another? ‘if you look at how people use social media’ Dr Short says, ‘they’re just passing time. We see this issue, and more serious cases of harassment, arising for young women especially. They are reporting cases of being liked repeatedly or tagged in stuff for someone else’s gratification. That’s what this is, it’s an attempt to get a reaction, not an authentic effort to try and communicate with them.’ In the case of the academic, he certainly wasn’t thinking about anything other than his own needs. I doubt it ever occurred to him that I might have moved on, which I had, and this his messages might be disruptive. The again, perhaps that was part of the thrill of being able to pop back into my life with minimal effort on a regular basis.

Another friend of mine, let’s call her Rachel, in her 30s, has also been breadcrumbed, hard. ‘I saw this guy for ages’ she tells me, ‘he’d go quiet every time he was shagging someone else (he basically had three of us on rotation). There was a proper pattern to it, every time he and I fell out he’d go totally dead, because his mind would be on one of the others – then he’d want to move on again at which point he’d start liking my posts and randomly commenting on stuff out of nowhere.’ Why does she think he chose to play out his love life this way? ‘he didn’t have to go out on a limb, it was just enough to sew the seed before he made the big play and started texting me again.’ For this guy, let’s call him the dick, breadcrumbing was a useful way of ensuring he had a few options on the back burner at all times.

As part of her work on cyberstalking Dr Shorthas been working with the police on low level online harassment. One friend of mine, Janice, 28 (obviously and definitely not her real name), had a very worrying experience after breaking up with someone she met on Tinder. He would like pictures of her from 2004 one day and then go silent. A week or so later he would tag her in a group devoted to a particular breed of dog he knew she loved or on a thread talking about a book that he knew was a favourite. Does Dr Short think breadcrumbers think about the impact they might be having? Often ‘they might not be considering how what they’re doing will play out on your timeline’ she says, ‘that you will get notifications, for instance. And certainly they’re not thinking about what you will see, think and feel in real time.’

I often feel like a luddite for day dreaming about a return to limited contact, hand written letters and long periods of silence. I worry that all the noise we’re bombarded by makes it difficult to discern what’s important and what’s dross. Dr Short doesn’t think I’m being hyperbolic, ‘the Internet eradicates our natural sense of empathy’ she says. ‘We don’t think about the impact of our actions because the cues to social consideration are far less available. Online you have to actively consider them rather than respond to them intuitively as you do when another person is in front of you.’

There's a sliding scale of breadcrumbing, as Brenda, 27, (that's right, not her real name) says 'there are two main types'. The first is the 'pen pal'. Brenda explains that this is someone who is 'literally never going to meet up with you and basically only messaging you when they're bored at work or need a confidence boost. I went on a date with a guy two years ago and he's been breadcrumbing me since then.' The second type? 'These guys see you as a potential back up shag, they send "whats ups" with every intention of meeting up but only if you fit into their framework and you're never ever going to.'

READ MORE: The Made In Chelsea Couples You Forgot About


Reality TV couples you forgot about - stacked

Jamie and Louise1 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 E4

Made In Chelsea: Jamie Laing and Louise Thompson

Remember when Jamie and Louise dated (much to Spencer Matthews' dismay) in 2012? Louise then left Jamie for Spencer, causing a very traumatic love triangle indeed. Poor Jamie.

TOWIE2 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

TOWIE: Mark Wright and Lauren Goodger

Mark Wright and Lauren Goodger's romance played out in the first couple of seasons of TOWIE, and it even involved a very short-lived engagement! However, after dating on and off for 10 years, the pair later ended their romance and Mark went on to marry actress Michelle Keegan.

THE HILLS3 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

The Hills: Jason Wahler and Lauren Conrad

She chose him over Paris, but that didn't stop Lauren Conrad's romance with Jason Wahler coming to an abrupt end. Following their rocky romance, the pair split and Lauren later married William Tell.

Love Island: Kady McDermott and Scott Thomas4 of 31

Love Island: Kady McDermott and Scott Thomas

Before she joined the cast of TOWIE to date Myles Barnett in 2018, Kady McDermott appeared on Love Island in 2016, where she found love with Ryan and Adam Thomas' brother Scott. Things didn't work out when they left the villa, with the pair announcing their split in 2017.

Made In chelsea5 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 E4

Made In Chelsea: Binky Felstead and Jamie Laing

Binks is now a mum to baby India, but remember when she dated Jamie Laing?!? After years of friendship, the two found it difficult to transition to an actual relationship, so decided to call it a day.

TOWIE6 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

TOWIE: Lydia Bright and James 'Arg' Argent

Before he started dating Gemma Collins, James 'Arg' Argent and Lydia Bright were one of TOWIE's golden couples. After being on and off for years, the pair ended things for good in 2016. Meanwhile, Lydia gave birth a baby girl, Loretta Rose, in February 2020.

Love Island: Sam Gowland and Georgia Harrison7 of 31

Love Island: Sam Gowland and Georgia Harrison

His on/off romance with fellow Geordie Shore star Chloe Ferry came to an end for good (we think) earlier this year but Sam Gowland first hit our TV screens on Love Island 2017, where he left the villa with former TOWIE star Georgia Harrison.

Made In Chelsea: Lucy Watson and Jamie Laing8 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 E4

Made In Chelsea: Lucy Watson and Jamie Laing

Jamie and Lucy were together for a bit and would even walk their dogs together. Not one for holding back, Lucy Watson has called the show 'incestuous' and she 'no longer wants to waste time with people like Jamie and Proudlock'. Ouch.

Chelsea9 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 E4

Made In Chelsea: Ollie Locke and Chloe Green

Topshop Heiress Chloe Green joined the MIC lot in 2011 to date Ollie Locke. Ollie had previously dated Gabby who he broke up with to explore his feelings for men, only to then end up with another woman. It did not go down well...He's now loved-up with husband Gareth Locke.

TOWIE10 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

TOWIE: Lucy Mecklenburgh and Mario Falcone

Before Lucy started dating former Coronation Street actor Ryan Thomas, she actually introduced Mario Falcone to TOWIE viewers as her boyfriend. Despite Mario proposing to Lucy on a luxury yacht, things didn't go to plan and their romance ended for good in 2013.

Made In Chelsea: Lucy Watson and Proudlock11 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 E4

Made In Chelsea: Lucy Watson and Proudlock

Ah yes, Lucy and Proudlock. They were the most swoon-worthy couple in SW3... oh, until Lucy found out that Proudlock was dating other women.

Love Island: Rykard Jenkins and Rachel Fenton12 of 31

Love Island: Rykard Jenkins and Rachel Fenton

After meeting on the show in 2016, Rykard and Rachel lasted 18 months in the real world, a lot longer than most Love Island couples!

Made13 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 E4

Made In Chelsea: Rosie Fortescue and Hugo Taylor

When Hugo was dating Millie Mackintosh in the show, he hooked up with her best friend Rosie. Millie then raised her glass to a party full of guests and said 'cheers to friendship'. However, Hugo later reconnected with Millie and the pair MARRIED in July 2018. Almost two years later, Millie gave birth to their first child, a baby girl, in May 2020.

TOWIE14 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

TOWIE: Charlie Sims and Ferne McCann

These two were actually together for SIX YEARS! But after Charlie decided to quit TOWIE, he later publicly dumped Ferne on Twitter, with reports suggesting he made her choose between him and the show.

THE HILLS15 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

The Hills: Justin Bobby and Audrina Patridge

Ever since Justin Bobby and Audrina split on The Hills, fans of the popular show have pleaded for them to rekindle their romance, even more so after Audrina announced she was divorcing her husband Corey Bohan.

Lucy and Spencer16 of 31

Made In Chelsea: Spencer Matthews and Lucy Watson

Spenny took Lucy to Paris in 2013 and we almost believed he had given up his womanising ways. We were wrong and he admitted to cheating on Lucy with several women. Spencer is now happily married with Vogue Williams and the pair have two adorable children together.

TOWIE17 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

TOWIE: Joey Essex and Sam Faiers

Another TOWIE couple which led to a failed engagement. Despite Sam and Joey dating from 2011, the pair didn't make it down to aisle, ending their relationship in 2014.

Made In CHelsea18 of 31

Made In Chelsea: Spencer Matthews and Louise Thompson

Louise joined the show as Spencer's (very despairing) girlfriend. Spencer being Spencer, couldn't stay faithful and resulted in a fair few teary scenes between the pair.

TOWIE19 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

TOWIE: Gemma Collins and Charlie King

Perhaps one of the strangest couples ever to grace TOWIE, The GC dated Charlie King in series four, but Charlie later announced he was gay on live TV.

Love Island: Tyla Carr and Jonny Mitchell20 of 31

Love Island: Tyla Carr and Jonny Mitchell

After breaking Camilla Thurlow's heart, a lot of Love Island fans forget that Jonny Mitchell later coupled up with Tyla Carr.Of course, the romance didn't last when they left the villa!

Made In Chelsea21 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 E4

Made In Chelsea: Alex Mytton and Binky Felstead

Binky and Alex were love's young dream (kind of) for two years until his constant cheating became unforgivable. It all worked out well though as she now has the cutest little baby girl with JP and is loved up with boyfriend Max Darnton.

The HIlls22 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

The Hills: Heidi Montag and Jordan Eubanks

Before she met, married and had a child with Spencer Pratt, Heidi Montag actually dated a guy called Jordan Eubanks on the show. Their romance was played out during season one, before they split.

TOWIE23 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

TOWIE: Jess Wright and Ricky Rayment

Potentially one of the messiest break-ups in TOWIE history! After Jess and Ricky dated for two years, things seemed to be going well until Ricky was accused of texting other women. After the split, the pair ended up having a bitter Twitter war. Jess later found love with William Lee-Kemp and got engaged in March 2020.

Jayde Nicole and Brody Jenner24 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

The Hills: Jayde Nicole and Brody Jenner

As well as his 'fake' relationships for the show with Lauren Conrad and Kristen Cavallari, Brody's romance with Jayde seemed pretty serious in 2008. Despite getting matching tattoos, the pair split in December 2009.

TOWIE25 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty Images

TOWIE: Lauren Pope and Kirk Norcross

Series two of TOWIE saw the lovable Lauren Pope hooking up with Kirk Norcross. Despite the pair getting his and hers nose jobs', the pair split just weeks after.

Love Island: Montana Brown and Alex Beattie26 of 31

Love Island: Montana Brown and Alex Beattie

They were one of the hottest couples ever to grace our screens, but things didn't work out for Montana Brown and Alex Beattie when they left the villa in 2017. In fact, their romance lasted just six weeks.

Geordie Shore: Vicky Pattison and Jay Gardner27 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty

Geordie Shore: Vicky Pattison and Jay Gardner

Her time on the show may be best remembered for her turbulent relationship with Ricci Guarnaccio but Vicky Pattison's first Geordie Shore relationship was actually with Jay Gardner back in series one.They were attracted to each other as soon as they stepped in the house but decided they were better off as pals after a series of rows.

Celebs Go Dating: Megan Barton-Hanson and Demi Sims28 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 E4

Celebs Go Dating: Megan Barton-Hanson and Demi Sims

Love Island's Megan Barton-Hanson and TOWIE star Demi Sims hit it off when they both appeared on Celebs Go Dating in 2019. Despite dating for a short time, the pair's romance was over before the series even ended.

TOWIE: Bobby Norris and Harry Derbidge29 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty

TOWIE: Bobby Norris and Harry Derbidge

He was one of the show's OG cast members but Harry Derbidge took a break from the TOWIE scene in 2011 before reappearing three years later (in some VERY skimpy swimwear) as Bobby Norris' boyfriend. It all ended in tears though when Harry confessed to sleeping with his ex on holiday in Tenerife.

Celebs Go Dating: Charlotte Dawson and Frankie Cocozza30 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 E4

Celebs Go Dating: Charlotte Dawson and Frankie Cocozza

They sign up to date us normal folk but those Celebs Go Dating lot just can't resist breaking the rules and getting it on with each other, can they? In 2017, Charlotte Dawson hooked up with X Factor bad boy Frankie Cocozza but it didn't last once the show ended and she's now loved-up with rugby player Matt Sarsfield.

Geordie Shore: Holly Hagan and James Tindale31 of 31
CREDIT: u00a9 Getty

Geordie Shore: Holly Hagan and James Tindale

She might be loved up with footballer fiancé Jacob Blyth now but back in series three of Geordie Shore, Holly Hagan enjoyed a fling with co-star James Tindale. Unfortunately, she was left heartbroken when he returned to the house for series four with a girlfriend.

The True Meaning Of Breadcrumbing

One thing all breadcrumbers have in common is laziness. They like to remind you they exist, or rather enjoy the validation in checking that you haven’t forgotten them. They check in, but never convert likes and messages into actions. They are to digital communication what puns are on the scale of wit, the lowest possible form. What they are really saying, Dr Short says is ‘I’m still here! I’m still here!’ and that, for her, ‘is one of the things that is so troublesome about it’. The breadcrumber is required to make little or no effort while the recipient might be thinking ‘great this person wants to get back in touch with me when, in reality, they might just be bored and lonely’.

If you’ve ever been breadcrumbed you’ll know how frustrating it is, to be at the beck and call of someone else’s whims, strung along and then, unceremoniously ignored until they get bored and reach out to you again in a moment of ennui or after having been dumped.

The point of leaving a trail of crumbs, in the Grimm fairy tale Hansel and Gretel, is that it helps you to find your way back to where you’re supposed to be. It doesn’t just lead you somewhere, the fairy tale breadcrumb trail leads home. Modern digital breadcrumb trails, on the other hand, lead you up the garden path at best and completely off course at worst.

WATCH NOW: Two Minute Makeover: Kylie Jenner On Her Lips & Other Beauty Secrets

This article originally appeared on The Debrief.

Just so you know, whilst we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website, we never allow this to influence product selections - read why you should trust us