It seems clear from the latest round of Oscar nominations, which favour films such as 1917, The Joker and Once Upon A Time In Hollywood but ignore erstwhile awards favourite Hustlers, that the best way to win an Oscar is to be a bloke in a violent or depressing film. If you do have the audacity to be a woman trying to win an award, you'll need to get out the micellar water.
Case in point, Jennifer Lopez. By all accounts, she does a phenomenal job as an actress and performer in Hustlers. And yet she’s been left out in the cold all awards season. Why? Well, comparing her to the women who have been nominated, it’s hard not to reach the conclusion that it’s because she played a conventionally attractive, very sexy sex worker in a not totally depressing film.
In 2005, Kate Winslet played a parody of herself in an episode of Ricky Gervais’ Extras, starring as a nun who hides Jewish people during World War II. Discussing the role, she says: I’ve noticed that if you do a film about the Holocaust you’re guarenteed an Oscar. I’ve been nominated for an Oscar four times and I haven’t won one. The whole world is saying, “why hasn’t Winslet won one? Schindler’s List, The Pianist, Oscars coming out of their arses”’.
Prophetic, it seems, as a decade later she was awarded the Academy Award for playing a Nazi in The Reader.
To illustrate the way that woman are obliged to select roles if they want to win awards, we looked at the last 25 years of best actress Oscar nominations, to work out what it is that a woman needs to do in order to win an Oscar.
Susan Sarandon - Dead Man Walking
Played a nun, based on a real person, wore no make up*.
Frances McDormand - Fargo
Played a pregnant police woman. Wore no make up.
Helen Hunt - As Good As It Gets
Played an overworked single mother. Wore no make up.
Gwyneth Paltrow - Shakespeare in Love
Spent half the film playing a boy, wore no make up
Hilary Swank - Boys Don’t Cry
Plays a trans man. Wore no make up.
Julia Roberts - Erin Brockovich
Plays a struggling single mother, wore quite a lot of make up.
Halle Berry - Monster’s Ball
Played a prison guard. Wore no make up.
Nicole Kidman - The Hours
Played Virgina Woolf. Wore no make up, but prosthetics.
Charlize Theron - Monster
Played a murderer. Wore no make up but gained weight for the role.
Hilary Swank - Million Dollar Baby
Played an aspiring boxer who eventually dies by assited suicide. No make up.
Reese Witherspoon - Walk The Line
Played June Carter. Wore make up. Sang.
Helen Mirren - The Queen
Played The Queen, wore a bit of Queen-y make up.
Marion Cotillard - La Vie En Rose
Played Edith Piaf throughout her entire life, including when she was disabled. Wore some make up.
Kate Winslet - The Reader
Plays an illiterate ex-Nazi. No make up.
Sandra Bullock - The Blind Side
Plays a suburban mother who adopts a young African American man. Unflattering hair and make up.
Natalie Portman - Black Swan
Plays a ballerina with mental health issues. Significant weight loss and only stage make up.
Meryl Streep - The Iron Lady
Plays Margaret Thatcher.
Jennifer Lawrence - Silver Linings Playbook
Plays Tiffany, who has bi-polar and doesn’t wear much make up.
Cate Blanchett - Blue Jasmine
Plays a socialite who loses all of her money in a Woody Allen film. Wore some make up.
Julianne Moore - Still Alice
Plays a woman with early onset Alzeimers. No make up.
Brie Larson - Room
Plays a woman who was abducted as a teenager, raped and lives in captivity. No make up.
Emma Stone - La La Land
Plays an actress in LA. Wears some make up.
Frances McDormand - Billboards
Plays a woman whose daughter was raped and murdered. Wears no make up.
Olivia Colman - The Favourite
Plays Queen Anne. Wears no make up
*No make up in the sense that it’s designed to look like a make up free face, rather than to make the character look more conventionally beautiful.
So, what can we learn from this list? That if you want an Oscar then your best bet is to take off all your make up, slap on some prosthetics (or perhaps gain some weight), star in a moderately depressing film.
Looking at the line-up of women who have won in the past 25 years, is it any wonder that Jennifer Lopez didn’t win any awards for her portrayal of a beautiful, sexy, sexual stripper who wears sequins, fur and hair extensions?
It seems the Academy is still attached to the idea that for a woman to be interesting, she must be someone you don’t want to have sex with.
Progress? What progress?
Let's have a look at last year's red carpet:
Oscars 2019: Red Carpet
Ashley Graham
Ashley Graham successfully made Zac Posen our new favourite designer in this stunning structured gown
Emilia Clarke at the 2019 Oscars
Emilia Clarke wore shimmering lavender Balmain
Marie Kondo at the 2019 Oscars
Considering it's only her first stint at the Oscars Marie Kondo absolutely nailed her look in this delicate v-neck Jenny Packham dress
Constance Wu at the 2019 Oscars
Crazy Rich Asian's Constance Wu was perfectly vernal in a daffodil-yellow tulle Versace gown
Elsie Fischer at the 2019 Oscars
15-year-old Elsie Fisher won the red carpet in a Thom Brown black three-piece-suit. She went for naughties-nostalgia with her hair, clipping it to one side with a barette.
Amandla Stenberg at the 2019 Oscars
Amandla Stenberg's delicate 1920's-feel Miu Miu dress was roughened-up by chain link detail
Melissa McCarthy at the 2019 Oscars
Melissa McCarthy wore the chicest monochrome pantsuit by Brandon Maxwell with a floor-sweeping cape
Regina King at the 2019 Oscars
Regina King dressed like the award winner she is in Oscar De La Renta
Linda Cardellini at the 2019 Oscars
Linda Cardellini's frothy pink gown was Schiaparelli-est dress to ever Schiaparelli
Yalitza Aparicio and Marina de Tavira at the 2019 Oscars
Yalitza wore custom Rodarte while Marina chose a J Mendel dress
Awkwafina at the 2019 Oscars
Awkwafina rocked a suit by DSquared2 but the real delight of her outfit was when she took a slug of tequila from her clutch later in the evening
Mark Ronson at the 2019 Oscars
This piped tux is by Maison Lance and Mark Ronson paired it with Roger Vivier shoes
Michelle Yeoh at the 2019 Oscars
This Elie Saab gown worn by Michelle Yeoh is from the spring 2019 couture runway
Octavia Spencer at the 2019 Oscars
Octavia Spencer donned midnight blue Christian Siriano and radiated classic elegance
Helen Mirren at the 2019 Oscars
Helen Mirren wore multi-coloured Schiaparelli, flashing the pleating detail around the skirt
David Oyelowo at the 2019 Oscars
David Oyelowo was one of many men on the red carpet rocking the trend for a velvet suit
Leslie Bibb at the 2019 Oscars
Leslie Bibb opted for wispy Armani Privé in this beautifully delicate nude dress
Gemma Chan at the 2019 Oscars
We love the roomy pockets on this capacious Valentino dress
Kacey Musgraves at the 2019 Oscars
Kacey Musgraves wore Giambattista Valli Couture
Jennifer Hudson at the 2019 Oscars
Jennifer Hudson wore this show-stopping scarlet gown by Elie Saab
Glenn Close at the 2019 Oscars
In custom-made Carolina Herrera Glenn Close dominated the top spaces of the best dressed lists
Amy Poehler at the 2019 Oscars
Take note from Amy Poehler: flares, ruffles and all-black are the new way to do a suit.
Maya Rudolph at the 2019 Oscars
Maya Rudolph in floral Giambattista Valli
Tina Fey at the 2019 Oscars
Tina Fey arrived in midnight-blue Vera Wang
Charlize Theron at the 2019 Oscars
Charlize Theronshowcased a brand new dark brown bob hairstyle in haute Couture Christian Dior
Allison Janney at the 2019 Oscars
Allison Janney wore a Pamella Roland dress and accessorized with Jimmy Choo heels
Brie Larson and Samuel L. Jackson at the 2019 Oscars
Brie Larson landed on the best-dressed lists in this column gown from Celine by Hedi Slimane
Amy Adams at the 2019 Oscars
Amy Adams accessorized with Cartier jewellery and opted for classic glamour with her dress in white and silver strapless Versace.
Emma Stone at the 2019 Oscars
Emma Stone in Louis Vuitton
Laura Dern at the 2019 Oscars
As one of the celebrities who chose to dress simple but striking, Laura Dern chose a Calvin Klein gown
Chadwick Boseman at the 2019 Oscars
Chadwick Boseman joined the ranks of gender non-conforming dressers in sequinned Givenchy
Lisa Bonet at the 2019 Oscars
Lisa Bonet honoured the late Karl Lagerfeld by wearing a dress from his last collection with Fendi
Rachel Weisz at the 2019 Oscars
Rachel Weisz wore a Givenchy couture two-piece with a vinyl caplet
Sarah Paulson at the 2019 Oscars
Sarah Paulson in bright pink Brandon Maxwell
Jennifer Lopez at the 2019 Oscars
Jennifer Lopez's space-age gown is by Tom Ford with Alex Rodriguez
Pharrell Williams and Helen Lasichanh at the 2019 Oscars
Pharrell Williams honoured Karl Lagerfeld in this camouflage shorts suit from Chanel
Queen Latifah at the 2019 Oscars
Queen Latifah layered Chopard jewellery over her dramatic sequinned gown
Paul Rudd at the 2019 Oscars
Paul Rudd wore a traditional navy tuxedo
Billy Porter at the 2019 Oscars
In one of the most-loved looks from the event Billy Porter showed up in Christian Siriano with a full skirt and sharp tuxedo jacket.
Chris Evans at the 2019 Oscars
Joining the ranks of velvet-loving male attendees on the red carpets Chris Evans switched up the classic tuxedo with a teal velvet blazer.