Last night Lottie Lion, the stand-out character/villain of this year’s Apprentice, was sent home following the interview round, which always makes up the penultimate episode of the series. Her time on the show was fraught with controversy, both about the fact that no one seemed to like her, the fact that she slept with a fellow contestant in the house, and about an alleged incident of racist language against another candidate during a row on WhatsApp after the show finished filming.
The incident put the BBC in a tricky position. They couldn’t re-shoot the show to get rid of Lion, and even if they could, she had provided most of the drama that the show so badly needed. So she was left as part of the show, but since leaving she has reportedly been banned from doing any press, and wasn’t allowed to take part in You’re Fired, the post-Apprentice rundown show that almost every candidate has taken part in. It’s a chance to pull back the narrative, put your side of the story to the wider world and show everyone how good you look when you didn’t get up at three in the morning to be screamed at in a shipping container in Essex or a sausage factory in Milton Keynes.
The BBC’s refusal to allow Lottie to continue in the show’s publicity, and the general public sentiment towards her is far, given that she told a fellow contestant who has Pakistani parents to, ‘shut up Gandhi’.But last night, before she was sent home, Lottie did illustrate one final, interesting story.
During the interview round of The Apprentice the candidates do a sort of speed dating round, only instead of dating it’s horrific crushing interviews designed to make them look and feel as stupid as humanly possible. One of the interviewers, Claudine Collins, takes the role of being a little bit nicer to the candidates and usually making them cry. Pamela burst into tears talking about how much she misses her mum who she apparently speaks to ‘four times a day’. Almost as soon as she had sat down, Collins gently asked Lion: ‘Claude and Karren [Brady] have said that people don’t like working with you?’
Initially Lottie gave it the bluster that had got her to the penultimate round of the show, saying, ‘while I like to be pleasant towards people, if they’re going to stand in the way of my success I don’t have a problem expressing my opinions.’ But then she paused and said, ‘I don’t like myself and parts of myself that I’ve seen in this process. The fact that I have fallen out with people and the fact that people don’t trust me as a leader... that’s personally hard to cope with.’
Either Lion is a really good actress, or there was a sense of genuine sadness in the way that she answered the question. In that moment, the UK (or at least the portion who watched The Apprentice) seemed to find sympathy for Lion. She seemed contrite. Defeated. And as narratives go, the bold and bolshy woman finally finding her humility is a good one. We like a redemption arc almost as much as we like to see people at the top of their games toppled. So many films, tv shows and books hinge on the person we hate turning out to have been good all along, that it’s no surprise we expect it from reality television too.
But here’s the thing. However sad and sorry Lottie seemed, she did direct a racist comment at a fellow contestant, and she hasn’t apologised for that fact. The BBC has excluded her from the rest of the publicity for the show for a reason. So as viewers we have to resist the tendency to forgive the baddie because we’re trained to do so in fiction.
Without wanting to condone cancel culture, we cannot forgive people for unquestionably poor behaviour, simply because of a moment of candid self reflection. Lion is only 19 years old, and it’s entirely possible that she could redeem herself both in the eyes of the public and in real life. But not without a genuine admission that she was wrong, and a demonstration that she intends to learn from her mistakes and do better.
Apprentice Candidates 2019
1 of 16Lottie Lion, 19
We say: Lottie Lion (best name in any series so far?) is a librarian, but looks like the kind of librarian you'd find in a teenage boy's imagination about what happens in a library, not an actual library. We're hoping that her practice in saying 'shhh' might make the 'girls' team more harmonious. Prediction: lots of comments from Lord Sugar about how book learning doesn't make you good in business, and literally thousands of book related puns. The Apprentice says: Lottie the librarian says she is 'very cut throat' and insists that she is no push over. She believes her poise and her 'powers of persuasion' are her greatest business qualities, noting that people with bad manners anger her and that she gets frustrated when things don't adhere to her high standards.
2 of 16Shahin Hassan, 36
We say: Every series needs a Shahin. He'll call adult women 'girls' for the entire series, make a comment in the first episode about how the boys 'have to win' because they're 'the best' and then cry when things get tiring. Prediction: He'll offer to be project manager in week one and suggest that they call the time something like Supermagneticspaffbomb or Goldfinger. The Apprentice says: Chartered engineer Shahin credits Elon Musk as one of his role models because he 'thinks outside the box', a quality he prides himself in having and thinks that his imagination will make him stand out from the other candidates.
3 of 16Iasha Masood, 27
We say: This is probably the best outfit anyone has ever worn on The Apprentice, which is disappointing because part of the fun is feeling sartorially superior to women wearing horse brooches and a jazzy scarf, or men who think that a bright blue suit and brown shoes is the high of chic. Prediction: We've got a feeling that Iasha might be slightly less of objectionable than your average contestant. We're calling top three right now. The Apprentice says: Iasha is an account manager who thinks her 'crazy, controversial, eccentric personality' will help her go far as she believes her 'natural persona' will help her win. But watch out for her enemies - Masood is not afraid of keeping her friends close but her enemies closer, and she says: 'I can read people just by looking at their body language, they won't realise it until it's too late – and checkmate'.
.jpg?auto=format&w=1440&q=80)
4 of 16Souleyman Bath, 20
We say: Disappointingly, Soleyman seems to actually be quite genuinely impressive. He's a para athlete which is just plain great. On the upside he's also a motivational speaker, so if we're really lucky he'll start saying things like 'I think outside the box. If I was an apple pie, the apples inside me would be oranges' (a classic from Alex, season 6). Prediction: semi finals at least, and a big row with the stupidest member of the 'boys' team in week one. The Apprentice says: Para athlete and motivational speaker Souleyman trains with the Great Britain Paralympic team as a sprinter, having been diagnosed with Retina Pigmentosa aged six. 'The less sight I have, the more imagination I gain, because what you see is what you see and what you don't see is when the magic begins,' he says.
5 of 16Scarlett Allen-Horton, 32
We say: We're very into this sheer bright green blouse, which has strong 'mean second wife who'd send you to boarding school the second she marries your dad' vibes. She says she doesn't like accepting help from other people, which is going to make an entirely team based competition interesting. Prediction: team mates can just about cope with her but she gets up Alan's nose and he cuts her in week six.The Apprentice says: Recruitment company owner Scarlett says that her upbeat personality means that people 'will often buy into her as a person,' but admits that she sometimes struggles to accept help from others. Could this cause fireworks in the show's infamous group tasks?
6 of 16Carina Lepore, 30
We say: Bow down to the year of the coloured trouser suit. Maybe she and Iasha can do a half and half thing and look like a refresher bar. Carina has done the fun and not at all annoying thing of pointing out her height (5"1) and describing herself as a pocket-rocket. Prediction: massive screaming row in week two and a Caesar stye backstabbing eviction in week 4. The Apprentice says: Carina owns an artisan bakery. She says she is a natural leader and that people latch onto her to benefit from the influence she carries. She believes it's 'written in the stars' that she'll be Lord Sugar's next Apprentice, describing herself as a 'pocket rocket' due to her height (5ft 1).
7 of 16Marianne Rawlins, 36
We say: Ah, the traditional American contestant who doesn't swear all the time or scream in people's faces. Also a member of the trouser suit club, Marianne looks like an actual grown up. Which unfortunately doesn't bode well in the Apprentice house. Prediction: Around week six we'll realise we've seen basically nothing from her, SurrAllan will accuse her of 'hiding' and she'll be toast. The Apprentice says: Marianne owns a risk management consultancy and moved from the US to the UK in 2017. She admits that she doesn't have a filter and may need to 'dial down her American-ness' and take a step back, as she says she can be too direct.
8 of 16Lubna Farhan, 33
We say: It's unclear whether she's wearing a dress with sleeves or a matching cardigan, but either way, we reckon Lubna is going to be hard as nails. In her bio she talks about being the 'whole package' which aren't words that a normal person would be capable of speaking. Prediction: she'll get close to being fired but will tell Lord Sugar that she had a hard childhood and he'll pretend not to care but be secretly moved. The Apprentice says: Finance manager Lubna says she believes she has the 'whole package' after turning herself into her own role model. A bookworm, the contestant describes herself as a 'dark horse', adding: 'I came from a council estate… I have made myself into something good and I'm on my way to becoming something great'.
9 of 16Jemelin Artigas, 34
We say: Jemelin gets the award for being the first person to misunderstand how percentages work and saying '1000%'. Prediction: will offer to be PM, lose control of the team because she doesn't want to be horrible and end up going home a moral victor but an actual loser. The Apprentice says: Network marketing consultant Jemelin claims she is '1000 percent committed' to winning every task but warns that she can be 'next-level stubborn' when it comes to getting her own way.
10 of 16Thomas Skinner, 28
We say: Thomas does actually run a proper business, which means that no one will listen to him for his entire time on the show. He gets kudos for being the first person to wear a checked suit in their PR pics though. Predictions: he'll offer to be PM for the complete wrong task and only avoid being fired by shouting 'Lord Sugar I've been working since I was three months old' in the boardroom. The Apprentice says: Pillow company owner Thomas started out in business aged 12, with a paper round, and later worked on the markets when he was 16. Since then he has set up his own pillow company, attributing his business success to his 'sharp', 'street wise' character.
11 of 16Lewis Ellis, 28
We say: Lewis has the shiniest suit in the whole line up, therefore will probably be the loudest voice. He'll be a total nightmare in tasks but quite fun in the house, so everyone will say nice things about him if he gets sent home. Prediction: He'll boast about how he's never read a book. Hopefully to Lottie the Librarian. The Apprentice says: Lewis is a digital marketing project manager and describes himself as a 'maverick', who believes his competitiveness and determination will see him through the process. He adds: 'I may not be the smartest guy in the room, but I'll sure as hell work harder.'
12 of 16Riyonn Farsad, 30
We say: Do not underestimate Riyonn. He's got a steely determination in his eye and he will definitely throw you under the bus. Prediction: he'll lay low for the first couple of weeks and then pounce on someone weak in the boardroom. Lord Sugar will tell him he's got a bobbins personality but not fire him. The Apprentice says: Events manager Riyonn invented his own card game which is part of his "little black book full of multi-million-pound ideas". He says his personality is his best asset, but won't let friends get in the way of coming out on top.
13 of 16Kenna Ngoma, 24
We say: Kenna makes alcoholic ice cream, so he obviously can't be all bad. He's gone for a burgundy suit which looks surprisingly great, and he used to play football for Man City, so honestly he seems quite cool. Prediction: he'll lay low for a few weeks, be made PM by Sugs and then win the task. Top three, we reckon. The Apprentice says: Before creating his alcohol-infused ice cream company in 2018, Kenna played semi-professional football for Manchester City before that was cut short by injury in 2013. Kenna believes he is enthusiastic with an "infectious personality", which he hopes will aid him to befriend the strongest candidates to help him build alliances.
14 of 16Ryan-Mark Parsons
We say: Ryan-Mark (is the the only person in the UK whose name is Ryan-Mark?) is only 19, so even more of a baby than Dean. We wish him well but honestly just looking at this photo we can tell that Alan is going to hate everything about him. Prediction: gone by week three because he's got soft hands, wears man jewellery and Lord Sugar can't bring himself to look at him. The Apprentice says: Ryan-Mark is an award-winning public speaker who admires the Queen and describes himself as the "epitome of luxury". Despite believing his best asset to be his ability to "forge a connection with anyone" he adds: "I'm not afraid to be ruthless when it comes to the other candidates."
15 of 16Dean Ahmed, 20
We say: Dean is only 20, so of course he's going to be awful, because we are all awful aged 20. Only he's going to broadcast his awfulness all over telly in a smart blue suit. Oh Dean. Prediction: he'll say something sexist and be cancelled on Twitter, throw himself into every single task, offer to be PM each week and mostly be ignored by the other contestants. The Apprentice says: Dean founded his sports management agency aged 15 and believes he is 'the definition of an entrepreneur', with confidence and emotional intelligence that are "off the charts". He believes his 'gift of the gab' could 'persuade anyone to do anything'.
16 of 16Pamela Laird
We say: Pam runs a beauty brand and describes herself as charismatic. We're not sure if you're really supposed to call yourself that, but fair play for the confidence. Prediction: she'll get a whole seven quid off something on the shopping task by flirting and Karen will raise her eyebrows in judgement. The Apprentice says: Beauty brand owner Pamela describes herself as "feisty and passionate" with a charismatic personality, which enables her to excel in sales. She says: "I love to be the under-estimated person in the room."