It Turns Out That Cheap Shampoos Aren’t ‘Bad’ For Your Hair After All, So Here Are The Best To Try

Previous reports criticised cheaper haircare products for their ingredients, so we asked the experts to weigh in.

shampoo

by Sameeha Shaikh |
Updated on

Some of us wouldn't think twice about parting with £35 for a skin-perfecting concealer (guilty as charged) or £72 for a skin-correcting vitamin C serum, but when it comes to buying the essentials like shampoo, our budget begins to run thin. According to a new study by expert haircare brand Philip Kingsley, on average respondents spend £11.60 on shampoo, with 66% spending less than £10. The study runs in conjunction with the return of cheap shampoo mega brands like Pantene, which made waves on TikTok over the festive period after influencer @alixearle went viral for using a bottle of Pantene's finest and claimed her hair was 'softer than it's ever felt,' leading her to question whether the myths around cheap shampoos like Pantene's were fake news.

In a video that has now amassed over six million views, Earle says, 'This may be crazy of me to say but how come when I come home and I use my expired Pantene shampoo and conditioner, my hair feels softer than it's ever felt? And, I'm starting to think like maybe I need to switch back.' After showing followers images of her former XXL lengths, Earle explains that Pantene's haircare was once key to the health of her bleached blonde butt-length hair, which leads her to question, 'so, is it a myth that it was bad for you or what?'

While we don't recommend using an expired bottle of anything, the question is worth exploring. Earle's video resurfaces debates around the idea associated with hair products which are deemed 'bad' because of their inclusion of ingredients like silicones and sulphates, said to compromise long-term hair health for short-term gains like softness and noticeable shine. Usually, it was the more affordable products said to contain higher volumes of said ingredients.

With 553.9K likes and 4,500 comments under Earle's video, that conversation has understandably been rife, with fellow influencers agreeing with Earle's pro-Pantene perspective. Lauren Mae wrote, 'I tried so many expensive shampoos bc I was told Pantene was “bad for your hair” but I used it for YEARS & my hair was so long. Switched back awhile ago & love it'. Likewise, Jade Brycki says, 'It’s literally all I use and my hair’s the best it’s been in YEARS.'

It's not just Pantene that is back in the spotlight. Mica said, 'LMAO i did the same thing. Went home used an old Tresemme shampoo & my hair was SO soft after! Maybe they’re staple affordable brands for a reason.' It seems the experts are on board, too.

Are silicones bad for your hair?

Reacting to Earle's TikTok, dermatologist Dr. Aamna Adel , explains, 'Erm, yes, it was a myth. I'm a dermatologist, I specialise in hair and I don't know who needs to hear this but silicones are not the devil when it comes to your hair. If you were somebody that used to use your Pantene shampoo religiously back in the day and then you just stopped because everyone was telling you how terrible it was for your hair, but at the time you noticed that your hair was just smoother and silkier and shinier – that was because of the silicones,' she shares in a separate video on the app.

Dr. Adel adds that the key thing to remember here is that not all silicones are built the same, and using the right ones can give you the best results for your hair type. Jade Summers, director of colour and cut at Hare & Bone, agrees and explains that silicones are used in products to seal the moisture into our hair and stop external aggressors from entering. Found in various shampoos, conditioners and styling products, they give an overall smoothness to the outer layer of the hair (the cuticle), leading to increased shine and manageability. The difference is, some silicones are water-soluble making it less likely to cause build up while others are not, and can end up weighing down your hair which requires more robust cleansing methods.

Summers adds that, rather than being a 'cheap' shampoo problem, 'silicones and sulphates are still found in professional shampoos, there was quite a scare mongering campaign for a while that would make people stay away from these ingredients as they were deemed "bad" for "everyone".' But as Summers puts it, the problem has become so rampant, legislation has been in place since 2017 to prevent brands from making such claims on the front of packaging in a bid to stop misguidance around these ingredients.

How to find the best shampoo

Instead of being bad for your hair, Anabel Kingsley, brand president and consultant trichologist at Philip Kinglsey, argues the misconceptions around 'good' and 'bad' ingredients is a product of the capitalist machine. 'There is usually a nugget of truth in these beliefs, but a lot of it is marketing. We have come a long way in terms of science, research, development and regulations. Ingredients that historically may have had a "bad" reputation have now been adapted to be more environmentally friendly (such as water-soluble silicones) and better regulated with the same great benefits.'

Kingsley says that, rather than looking into the individual ingredients on a shampoo label, it's important to consider the quality of the ingredients, the percentage of them contained within the formula and what else is included, as ingredients interact with each other and can balance each other out. It is, therefore, much more effective to choose a shampoo based on your hair texture and/or scalp condition.

For instance, Summers explains that dryer, colour treated and curly hair will always benefit from moisture, so look out for natural oils such as roucou oil, which is enriched with essential fatty acids and antioxidant properties. Bleached hair types should embrace shampoos containing amino acids that help to strengthen hair, while those prone to dandruff will quickly come to rely on selenium sulphide, which boasts anti-fungal properties and reduces oil that contributes to the proliferation of the condition.

Grazia Beauty's favourite cheap shampoos
Grazia Beauty's favourite cheap shampoos

Consider the myth busted. If, like the rest of TikTok right now, you are intent on reverting back to high street haircare heroes, here's our edit of the very best.

Shop: The Best Cheap Shampoos To Buy Now

Formulated for damaged hair, this classic Pantene shampoo features active Pro-V nutrients including antioxidants and purifying ingredients to strengthen hair from the inside-out. By reversing the signs of damage, it gently cleanses while works against styling damage, prevents the split ends and bolstering shine and smoothness.

Sameeha Shaikh, beauty writer, says: 'The TikTok girlies weren't lying about this one. Its rich formula and classic scent instantly had me hooked, but it was the healthy look and feel of my newly compromised hair (having just colour treated my virgin hair for the very first time) that made me stay loyal to this classic shampoo. Breakage? Reduced. Annoying constant knotting? Thankfully, gone.'

Specially made for coarse, curly and coily hair types, this shampoo contains an ultra-nourishing blend of vitamin E, coconut oil and shea butter to boost radiance, softness, and your natural texture. The rich lather helps to lift dirt, impurities and build-up from the hair with ease, too.

Sameeha Shaikh, beauty writer, says, 'This is one of the first "cheap" shampoos that helped me to kick my high end shampoo habit. Its sumptuous formula, rich lather and easy-on-the-eye packaging made it an easy swap, as did its effects on my lengths which were left supple, smooth with my natural waves in tact.'

A long-time bathroom staple, this floral-scented Herbal Essences shampoo is loaded with a blend of
plant-based, naturally-derived nutrients like real Rose essences, which are handpicked in Grasse. Aside from its nostalgic scent which is scientifically proven to boost moods, it imparts a velvety hardworking lather, two times more nourishment, and touchable softness.

Sameeha Shaikh, beauty writer, says: 'This one is a real blast from the past and is as nostalgic as it gets when it comes to beauty, for me at least. The familiar floral scent instantly takes me back to my school days but the formula has definitely seen an upgrade. Expect, soft, shiny hair and lasting hydration.'

Rice water has steadily grown in popularity thanks to its transformative effects on our skin and hair, but if fermenting your own concoction seems a chore, Garnier has you covered. Geared towards those of us with long, dull hair left damaged by environmental stress, this shampoo is enriched with rice water and starch to rehydration, replump, and reseal cuticles for smoothness and reflection-ready shine. 

Sameeha Shaikh, beauty writer, says: 'I've been using rice extract in my skincare byway of K-Beauty products for some time now and have seen a noticeable difference in levels of inflammation on my skin, based on these results I was keen to see how rice water would fair on my hair. Expectedly, this shampoo worked a treat, foaming up nicely before leaving behind a long-lasting shine that in no way looks greasy.'

This stellar range from L’Oréal Paris hones in on hero skincare ingredient glycolic acid to penetrate the hair’s fibre with its small molecular weight to help bolster shine, smoothness and strength from within. Used as the first step in the brand's answer to an at-home glossing routine, this shampoo is the foundation you need for that next-level shine.

Sameeha Shaikh, beauty writer, says: 'This shampoo is a stark example of high street brands doing what they do best. It is no-fuss, affordable, delightfully good smelling and does exactly what you need it do it. I especially loved how long I could go between wash days as the shampoo did a great job of clarifying my scalp and sapping up residue without leaving behind any greasy, heavy feeling.'

TikTok has recently gone wild for Alberto Balsam's Raspberry shampoo thanks to its ability to leave behind lasting scent and soft, supple strands.

Rachael Martin, beauty editor, says: 'The first thing I noticed about the Alberto Balsam Raspberry Shampoo was the colour. It's very pink and doesn't exactly feel like the height of sophistication. But this is hardly a deal breaker - it's £1, after all. It's the scent that hits next - think a heady mesh of sugar and raspberries that feels sickly initially, but becomes more subtle (and actually quite lovely) as the day wears on. In shower the shampoo lathers up easily, leaving strands that feel clean and void of any dry or brittle texture- there's the addition of moisturising Vitamin B5 to thank for that. I followed with a dollop of the complementing conditioner (also £1) and then rough dried my hair. And I really was pleasantly surprised. My hair did feel shinier and it did feel softer. I'm prone to tangling and a frizzy, lifted cuticle and both bugbears were minimised.'

Pros

  • Long-lasting fragrance
  • Silicone free
  • Contains Vitamin B5
  • Suited to all hair types

Cons

  • Packaging doesn't feel very chic (but for £1 who are we to argue)

First and foremost a clarifying shampoo, this is deep cleanser helps to remove buildup all while enriching the hair with moisture.

Renee Washington, fashion and beauty assistant, says: 'This shampoo has been a staple ever since my childhood. It cleanses my hair so well without completely stripping it of its natural oils. I find using it means I can even ease up on the conditioning steps after because my hair isn’t so dry. Also don’t let the brown colour throw you, it lathers amazingly, and smells just like a vanilla treat.'

Pros

  • Gentle enough for daily use
  • Clinically proven to relieve itchy scalps
  • Mild acids make it safe to use on colour-treated hair

Cons

  • May not be thorough enough for tougher scalps and hair types

Made for for salon-quality, at home. This well-loved shampoo helps to forge stronger hair that is enriched with a covetable more shine, less frizz and long-lasting suppleness, thanks to its hero ingredient argan oil sourced straight from Morocco, which is loaded with vitamin E and fatty acids to help seal up the hair cuticle and in turn promote healthier-looking shiny hair. 

Sameeha Shaikh, beauty writer, says: 'I once picked up a travel sized version of this shampoo and the conditioner at duty-free just before heading out on a girls trip to the South of France. A day into the holiday, I needed to restock after my friends quickly caught onto the shampoo's brilliant benefits – safe to say we've all been hooked ever since.'

For those looking for a 'clean hair experience' that really does protect the integrity of your natural hair texture, look to Maui Moisture. It is vegan and free from sulfated surfactants, silicones, artificial colours, mineral oils and ALES, and instead comes equipped with a botanical blend of natural ingredients like exotic bamboo fibres, neem oil and  castor oil to fortify hair from root to tip. 

Sameeha Shaikh, beauty writer, says: 'I have naturally wavy hair and for a brief period decided to completely embrace my natural texture with the right haircare and styling tools. This shampoo was key to my natural haircare game, it provided sustained nourishment throughout the week (I would wash once a week) and left my waves defined, radiant and bouncy, all while lifting residue left behind by various styling products that also supported my texture throughout the previous week.'

Colour treated hair becomes sensitive to external aggressors like the sun and pollution as the natural protective layer of fibres becomes compromised. This clever shampoo contains UVA + UVB filters to help fortify hair, while locking in colour.

Joely Walker, head of beauty, says: 'As a dye-hard blonde I need a shampoo that works with my colour, not against it (be wary of deep cleanse shampoos that can cause colour fade). This also leaves my somewhat frazzled, heat-damaged hair feeling soft and smooth after every single wash.'

Pros

  • Great for all hair
  • Plant-powered, ethical
  • Affordable

Cons

  • One Sephora reviewer claimed this dried out their scalp

Known for its natural ingredients and cutting-edge technology, this Italian brand prides itself on creating quality haircare products that are as indulgent as they are efficacious. Case in point, the In Oud Wash.

Sameeha Shaikh, beauty writer, says: 'As someone who has tried an endless list of shampoos, both fragrance-free and scented, I have to admit that I am much more inclined to the latter. And this shampoo brings my favourite fragrance note into focus. Expect a refined woody and spicy balance of Agarwood resin to flood your bathroom, while an emollient active blend of organic mallow, blueberry and olive oil extracts moisturise and cleanse in tandem.'

With nourishing Australian macadamia nut oil at its core, this wildly popular pick promises to rest ore and refresh dry, frizzy hair.

Rachael Martin, beauty editor, says: 'If I want my hair to look beautifully smooth and shiny then my failsafe is Aussie's Miracle Moist - I even used it on my wedding day. It's cheap as chips, yes, but you best believe it works like a dream. Lather up and let the macadamia nut oil get to work - even the most parched strands appear refreshed and revived. Follow with the 3 Minute Miracle mask for a hefty hit of moisture.'

Loaded with acacia honey, acacia flower and beeswax, this shampoo prioritising strength and nourishment, to build the resilience of your hair while leaving it glazed, too.

**Cassie Steer, acting beauty director, says: '**This is the shampoo that brings my rebellious, frazzled hair back from the brink. Supremely nourishing (although it may be a tad too weighty for finer-haired girls), it’s ridiculously good value for money and genuinely holds it's own against its luxe counterparts. Smells good too.'

Pros

  • Sustainable
  • Best for oily hair types
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Dry hair types should steer clear

Think Simple's gentle skincare approach but this time for your hair. The soothing shampoo effectively cleanses and revives hair, all while tending to those of us with sensitive scalps.

Sameeha Shaikh, beauty writer, says: 'Packed with moisture-loving pro-vitamin B5, chamomile oil and glycerin, this gentle shampoo focuses on hair-loving ingredients sans harsh chemicals, artificial colour, perfume and animal-derived ingredients. The result? Natural shine that won't disrupt the balance of your hair and scalp.'

Expertly formulated with Biotin (a vitamin B7 that is a great aid to healthy skin, nails, and hair) as well as hyaluronic acid, this shampoo works to strengthen hair while thickening by 200% and helping to reduce hair loss caused by breakage. It works especially well on fine, thin hair that is need of an instant plumping boost.

Sameeha Shaikh is Grazia's beauty writer, working across all categories to bring you insights on the latest trends, industry news and the products you need to know about, viral or not (most probably viral).

Main image: TikTok @@alixearle, @abbeyyung, and @nicole.bibiano

Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us